Investment Project Dispute Resolution: Lessons from the Conflicts

Vietnam has become an attractive destination for both domestic and international investors, particularly in the real estate, industrial, and infrastructure sectors. However, the increase in investment has also led to a rise in disputes within these projects. The causes of such disputes include legal differences, conflicting interests between stakeholders, and the uncertainties arising from the legal and economic environment. This article analyzes common types of investment project disputes, lessons learned from typical conflicts, and effective legal solutions in the current context of Vietnam.

Common Types of Investment Project Disputes in Vietnam

1. Disputes Relating to Investment Contracts

Investment contracts form the essential legal framework for establishing relationships between investors, partners, and stakeholders. However, many disputes arise due to unclear, poorly structured, or non-compliant contractual provisions. For example:

Breach of Contractual Obligations: Some investors fail to fulfill their financial, progress, or technical standards as stipulated in the project.
Unjustified Termination of Contracts: One party unilaterally terminates the contract without legal grounds, causing significant damage to the other party.

2. Disputes Between Shareholders and Investment Partners in Investment Projects

In joint venture projects, conflicts often occur between shareholders over rights, responsibilities, and development strategies. Common issues include:

Profit Distribution Disputes: Caused by a lack of transparency or inconsistent calculation methods.
Abuse of Management Authority: A shareholder gaining control or making unfair decisions that harm the interests of other shareholders.

3. Disputes with Government Authorities and Third Parties in Investment Projects

Large-scale projects often face disputes related to zoning, permits, or land compensation. Key causes include:

Policy Changes: Sudden legal changes that affect the feasibility of the project.
Conflicts of Interest with Local Communities: Inadequate compensation or negative environmental impacts affecting residents.

Typical Legal Conflicts in Vietnamese Projects Through Practical Cases

Dispute in the X Urban Area Project (Location confidential for client information):

A foreign investor signed a contract to develop a large urban area in Vietnam but faced delays due to local authorities adjusting the land-use planning. This led to a claim for damages and a threat of arbitration at an international center. This case highlights the following lessons for investors:

Limitations in Ensuring Legal Stability: International investors often have high expectations for the transparency and stability of local regulations.
Risk Prevention Strategy: Contracts should include provisions to manage risks and disputes arising from force majeure or policy changes.

Dispute Among Shareholders in the Y Industrial Park Project (Location confidential for client information):

A dispute arose between shareholders of an industrial park project in Vietnam over management rights. A major shareholder used its veto power to block an investment increase, causing delays in the project. This case highlights:

The Importance of Shareholder Agreements: Clear provisions regarding voting rights, profit distribution, and management responsibilities are crucial.
Resolution through Arbitration or Court: The parties chose commercial arbitration to resolve the dispute, saving time and costs compared to court proceedings.

Recent Legal Changes in Vietnam and Their Impact on Investment Projects

After the XV National Assembly session, several important legal changes directly affected investment projects in Vietnam, including:

1. Amendments to the Investment Law and Enterprise Law

New Regulations on Conditional Business Sectors: Some industries were added to the list, requiring investors to meet higher standards.

Increased Corporate Responsibility: Investment companies must comply with regulations on environmental protection, labor, and financial transparency.

2. Revised Land Law

Market-Based Land Valuation: This creates a more equitable framework but also increases investment costs.

Clearer Land Expropriation Process: This helps reduce conflicts with local communities.

3. Decree on Managing Industrial Real Estate

Stronger Financial Control: Projects must demonstrate financial capacity through bank guarantees or clear funding sources.

These changes present opportunities but also significant challenges for investors. Disputes are expected to increase if parties are not adequately prepared legally.

Effective Legal Solutions for Project Investors:

Early Risk Prevention Measures:

Comprehensive Legal Due Diligence: Before investing, conduct a thorough review of the project’s legal status, including land use, permits, and partners.
Drafting Detailed Contracts: Clearly define provisions related to rights and obligations, dispute resolution, and compensation.

Dispute Resolution Approaches:

Negotiation and Mediation: These are preferred methods to save time and costs.
Commercial Arbitration: With its confidentiality and flexible procedures, arbitration is becoming the top choice for complex disputes.
Litigation in Court: When no agreement can be reached, the court is the final option, requiring thorough preparation of evidence and arguments.

The Strength of La Défense Law Firm in Investment Project Dispute Resolution

La Défense Law Firm has established its leading position in investment dispute resolution thanks to several key factors:

Practical Experience: Our legal team has handled numerous complex cases, from contract disputes to shareholder conflicts.
Expertise in Local and International Law: We stay up-to-date with the latest legal changes and creatively apply them to protect our clients’ interests.
Comprehensive Approach: From consultation and negotiation to litigation, we offer complete and optimal solutions.

Resolving investment project disputes requires not only deep legal knowledge but also the ability to navigate trends and real-world contexts. La Défense Law Firm is proud to be a trusted partner for investors, providing peace of mind and efficiency in every transaction. Let us accompany you on the journey to success.

Read more at: